8 Comments
User's avatar
T K Hall's avatar

This is vital stuff. I abandoned a story that didn't work recently and I've been doing a lot of thinking about why, without ever coming to a really definite conclusion. But I think you might have solved it for me! The story didn't have a concrete WHY. It had themes I was vaguely interested in, but nothing I would talk passionately about, let alone scream from the rooftops. A story is a vehicle for carrying important truths. I don't think you have to know what those truths are from the get-go, but at some point in the planning or the writing they have to get hold of you. If they don't, the story will never come fully alive. Great post, Graham, many thanks!

Expand full comment
Graham Strong's avatar

So glad it helped!

I agree -- you don't need to know the whole "Why" at the beginning. I'm a confirmed pantser, and I often find the Why along the way.

However, (a) knowing your "Why" earlier makes it easier, and (b) taking a closer look at your "Why" when you're stuck can often help you get unstuck. (At least, that's been my experience in both my fiction AND day-job non-fiction writing.)

Hope you can get that story whipped into shape now!

Expand full comment
Meg Oolders's avatar

Stellar post. Thanks for the repeated reminder to read Save the Cat, which remains unopened on my bedtable. I have a goal to START EFFING WRITING my next novel this month. This month that has officially arrived and is no longer on the horizon. I'm off to find my WHY now. 🥂

Expand full comment
Graham Strong's avatar

Thanks Meg!

As mentioned in this post, I've been EFFing writing my latest novel, and I'm happy with the results so far. I haven't had enough time with it yet to understand *exactly* how well it's working, but I plan to report back here when I have some more evidence.

Good luck with your novel! Yes, start with Save the Cat. I'm a pantser who wishes he could plot, and this book gave me some things to think about in terms of story without actually committing a framework to paper... lol

And congrats again on your poetry collection! (I encourage anyone else reading this comment to click on Meg's Stock Fiction link to check that collection out...)

Expand full comment
Terry Fallis's avatar

Excellent advice, Graham, as usual. Thought-provoking.

Expand full comment
Graham Strong's avatar

Thanks Terry -- glad you like it!

Expand full comment
Peggy Van de Plassche's avatar

Absolutely Brillant! TY Graham. Love it.

Expand full comment
Graham Strong's avatar

Thanks Peggy -- glad you do!

Expand full comment